Tradable Pollution Permits Explained
By Steve Bain
Tradable pollution permits are created by governments as a means of tackling this 'negative externality' that arises from industrial production. They have gained a lot of interest in recent years due to concerns over global warming and the influence of carbon emissions in speeding up that process.
Now, in this article, I won't be getting into the whole political debate over whether or not the carbon emissions that result from our current industrial production practices are causing any significant extra warming effects on the global climate.
Nor will I discuss the likelihood of getting any firm global commitment to reduce emissions given that the biggest polluter, China, is intending to construct hundreds more coal-fueled power stations in the coming years. Further questions arise as to whether India is likely to produce more emissions as it too develops, or the rest of the world's poor countries too.
Raising basic standards of living is understandably the first, second, and third priority for the people in these countries.
Given that, for the world's poor, reducing their carbon footprint effectively means that they and their children will need to go cold and hungry at night, they might struggle to see the fairness of doing that solely on the basis that people in the rich countries have made sacrifices and set an example for them, e.g. by switching to hybrid 4x4's instead of the old gas guzzlers!
The politics embroiled in all of this is understandably complex, and likely to be extremely combative before any workable solutions or compromises are agreed - much less followed up and enforced. You may confidence in the Paris Accord, I have none at all!
Thankfully for me, this is an economics focused website and not a politics website, so I will stick with an explanation of tradable pollution permits and how they work.
Allocation of Permits
The first problem with deciding which firms should receive the tradable pollution permits, and which should not, starts with identifying what the total amount of current emissions is, and what society desires it to be.
Once this is established we need to know which particular industries are creating unacceptable amounts of carbon emissions and then pass regulations requiring the firms within those industries to possess permits for the pollution that they create.
These permits may be allocated for free in proportion to the level of output that each firm produces, or they could be sold for a fee. The point is that the government would need to set an overall industry pollution level that is lower than the existing level.
Regardless of how the permits are allocated, they are tradable, meaning that those firms which value permits the highest can purchase them from the firms that value them relatively less.